Found this thread as concerned I'm suffering a similar problem with my 1.4 BBY engined A2.
I've literally not done anything just yet to look at it as am in all manner of different cars all the time due to my job. Anyway, my suspicion is the throttle body and the car effectively running on choke the whole time. This would explain why it runs absolutely fine but the mpg is dire at present and far worse than it used to be. Have had the car more than five years and done many thousands of miles, so I know something's up. But, no light on, temp looks okay and temp sensor should be fine. Lambda sensor might be at fault, as did previously have the light on, but it isn't at the mo and hasn't been for a while. Gave it a throttle body clean (second in my time with the car) last year and, I think, that's when the issues might have started. I reset the throttle body as you're supposed to using vagcom so perhaps it's not set right. Not sure if any of this will help your case, but as a rough guide I used to get a consistent 350-400 miles from a tank depending on long runs or town driving. 250 is dire and about what I'm getting at present too. Hope this helps!