Do you want an electric A2?

The economic theories of supply and demand may lead us to hope for cheaper fuel when internal combustion engines become less common. But in my country, which is sparsely populated, with few large cities, and long distances, I fear that the costs of transporting fuel to all corners of the country will be shared among fewer customers - this will lead to more expensive petrol/diesel. In addition to that, it will not be surprising if there are even more political measures to get us over to Electric vehicles more quickly.

I've driven quite a few electric cars, and can't wait. They are a joy to drive, and work mostly without a problem. And they are cheap to run!

By the way: This is how a new Service Station in Norway looks. The future is EVs, so the speedloaders is placed on the front, and I have to go to the back of the station to fill up my A2.

This is how the future looks!

IMG_1651.jpeg

IMG_1650.jpeg
 
Last edited:
They wont be cheap to run in England if the Government decides to go ahead with 5 pence per mile tax on them though.
 
Money really, the more electric cars, the less income, they are loosing revenue from road Tax :)
Wow... That`s really stupid.

If the UK is to meet its climate emission targets, it must be a political goal to get as many Electric cars on the road as possible. This will only slow down that development.

The success here in Norway has two main reasons:

1. Politicians have made it cheap to both buy and use electric cars. (This, of course, means that the state loses revenue. But you don't have to spend money on expensive climate measures elsewhere in the budget.)

2. An impressive network of charging stations has been built around the country. Even small places have their charging station. It's already much harder to find a fuel pump with 98-octane gas than a fast charger.

The result of all this is that people have grown in to both trusting, and loving the new technology. The last combution engine driven car sold in Norway is only a couple of years away.
 
And they are cheap to run!
There are a number of YT videos from owners in the UK showing the cost of running an EV is cheaper than ICE but they tend to have their own PV and/or use off-peak electricity like Octopus. Capital costs and depreciation are higher at the moment.

A recent article says Motorway Ultra-fast charging is 65p/kWh; Rapid charging: 55p/kWh; and Fast charging: 44p/kWh.

Octopus Go 12p / kWh rate for four hours every night (between 12.30 and 4.30am or Octopus Agile where there are low but variable overnight rates and high rates 4pm-7pm - all notified 24 hours in advance (e.g. on 18 Jan 2023 the average was 30p/kWh and varied +3p/-4p). As a comparison my green tariff (not Octopus) is now almost 34p kWh (excluding the daily fixed charge).

Norway has an abundance of green electricity from hydro. So much that it exports a lot. It would be interesting to know the Norwegian electricity costs.
 
Another A2 EV conversion has finished, not without trials and tribulations getting it approved.

Guy called Johannes Hübner in Germany. I get the impression he has done a number of none A2 conversions and was asked by a Swede (who has 4 A2s) if he could convert an A2 for him. I think Johannes is more of a software and electrical engineer as he has written the software to connect the A2 instruments and controls from the CanBus to the EV inverter/battery controller.

The vehicle has a 24kWh battery from a Leaf and a Prius motor and inverter. The rear seats have been removed to fit the batteries both below the floor and above in 2 layers. This keeps the centre of gravity forward and simplifies the wiring. Winter energy consumption is an actual 13kWh/100km which I calculate as 185 km / 115 miles but of course a EV is generally used from 90% to 20% so real range is less. It was built to handle a 80km round trip commute.

This first video gives an overview of the conversion and includes a list of things rejected by the certifying authority. This video is in German so switch on the translate captions.


This recent 2nd video takes us through the changes and all the various components in the engine compartment. This shows how much more that batteries and motors are needed. To deliver the vehicle to Sweden he has fitted a temporary CCS charging socket. Normally the vehicle will be home charged.


Both videos have a test drive.
Hats off for all the work that has been done and conversion.
But I would be really reluctant to use such converted car. New EVs from mainstream manufacturers burn and probability of a fire in such conversion project is miles higher. No, thank you.

I had a petrol car with aftermarket LPG and after 5 years I have decided to replace ALL the rubber tubes for water collant, etc. When removing them they just broke, while OEM parts were still in perfect operating state. I learned my lesson there. And LPG conversion has been done from a reputable conversion garage.
 
Wow... That`s really stupid.

If the UK is to meet its climate emission targets, it must be a political goal to get as many Electric cars on the road as possible. This will only slow down that development.

The success here in Norway has two main reasons:

1. Politicians have made it cheap to both buy and use electric cars. (This, of course, means that the state loses revenue. But you don't have to spend money on expensive climate measures elsewhere in the budget.)

2. An impressive network of charging stations has been built around the country. Even small places have their charging station. It's already much harder to find a fuel pump with 98-octane gas than a fast charger.

The result of all this is that people have grown in to both trusting, and loving the new technology. The last combution engine driven car sold in Norway is only a couple of years away.
Great to have a first hand guy from Norway. Interesting to read this. How many EV fires do you have? How is the state od underground parking? Are EVs allowed in? Since the second ship fire, that should be a really good discussion point.
 
There are no restrictions on electric cars in inhouse or underground car parks, tunells or on ferries here in Norway.

Yes, electric cars occasionally catch fire. But so do ICE cars. In fact, the most dramatic car fire in recent Norwegian history is a fire that started in an Opel Safira in a car park at the airport outside Stavanger in south-west Norway.


My point is that fuel-powered cars also catch fire every once in a while. But we have become so used to that technology that we don't talk about that problem. In other words, the problem of fire in electric cars is, in my view, greatly exaggerated, because it is linked to new technology.

Conserning the fire on that Car Carrying ship: Fires like that is nothing new. If you do a historic search you will find several such fires from the time that all cars where Internal Combustion Engine-powered.

This example is from 1998: https://safety4sea.com/cm-maritime-history-fire-on-board-car-carrier-eurasian-drea

Why didn`t that fire cause an national discussion about trasnportation of dangerous flamable cars? ;)

I think it all boils down to the natural human skepticism of anything new.
 
There are no restrictions on electric cars in inhouse or underground car parks, tunells or on ferries here in Norway.

Yes, electric cars occasionally catch fire. But so do ICE cars. In fact, the most dramatic car fire in recent Norwegian history is a fire that started in an Opel Safira in a car park at the airport outside Stavanger in south-west Norway.


My point is that fuel-powered cars also catch fire every once in a while. But we have become so used to that technology that we don't talk about that problem. In other words, the problem of fire in electric cars is, in my view, greatly exaggerated, because it is linked to new technology.

Conserning the fire on that Car Carrying ship: Fires like that is nothing new. If you do a historic search you will find several such fires from the time that all cars where Internal Combustion Engine-powered.

This example is from 1998: https://safety4sea.com/cm-maritime-history-fire-on-board-car-carrier-eurasian-drea

Why didn`t that fire cause an national discussion about trasnportation of dangerous flamable cars? ;)

I think it all boils down to the natural human skepticism of anything new.
How can ICE cars catch fire? Wouldn’t they just melt? 😂😂😂😂
 
My problem with the electric cars is that they should have been small, light, nimble and *affordable*, but all that went down the drain because market wanted EV SUVs that cost tens of thousands. On top of it, none of them would be repairable, they will be appliances with most likely planned obsolescence forcing you to replace them at regular intervals. All this means that the benefit for the environment would be questionable.

Also, can't recall the source but I read a very interesting article argumenting that there simply isn't enough raw materials on this planet to manufacture all the batteries needed to replace all the ICE vehicles with EV counterparts which inevitably means that not everyone will be able or allowed to drive. *Shudder*
 
Last edited:
Wow... That`s really stupid.
Yes, they are! The electricity price here is determined by the price of gas. Electricity is also subject to carbon taxes - even solar and wind! Gas however is not, even though it's a fossil fuel! New gas and oil fields in the North Sea are being enabled by huge government subsidies; renewables receive no subsidies. These people are either ignorant and scientifically and economically illiterate or they are receiving large amounts of money from fossil fuel companies.

RAB
 
Yes, they are! The electricity price here is determined by the price of gas. Electricity is also subject to carbon taxes - even solar and wind! Gas however is not, even though it's a fossil fuel! New gas and oil fields in the North Sea are being enabled by huge government subsidies; renewables receive no subsidies. These people are either ignorant and scientifically and economically illiterate or they are receiving large amounts of money from fossil fuel companies.

RAB
Or both @RAB i fear!
 
Another A2 EV conversion has finished, not without trials and tribulations getting it approved.

Guy called Johannes Hübner in Germany. I get the impression he has done a number of none A2 conversions and was asked by a Swede (who has 4 A2s) if he could convert an A2 for him. I think Johannes is more of a software and electrical engineer as he has written the software to connect the A2 instruments and controls from the CanBus to the EV inverter/battery controller.

The vehicle has a 24kWh battery from a Leaf and a Prius motor and inverter. The rear seats have been removed to fit the batteries both below the floor and above in 2 layers. This keeps the centre of gravity forward and simplifies the wiring. Winter energy consumption is an actual 13kWh/100km which I calculate as 185 km / 115 miles but of course a EV is generally used from 90% to 20% so real range is less. It was built to handle a 80km round trip commute.

This first video gives an overview of the conversion and includes a list of things rejected by the certifying authority. This video is in German so switch on the translate captions.


This recent 2nd video takes us through the changes and all the various components in the engine compartment. This shows how much more that batteries and motors are needed. To deliver the vehicle to Sweden he has fitted a temporary CCS charging socket. Normally the vehicle will be home charged.


Both videos have a test drive.
Update. Johannes delivers the electric A2 to Thomas - a 350km journey using a temporary CSS charging port that gets damaged towards the end but he made it. Thomas will charge at a lower rate using his PV panels.


 
I'm not sure why the new owner would not want a Type 2 charge point on the car. It wouldn't stop him from charging from his solar system and he could also charge elsewhere. Also I wouldn't charge a Nissan Leaf battery using CCS (DC) since there's no battery temperature control. The same applies to an E-Up.

RAB
 
I'm not sure why the new owner would not want a Type 2 charge point on the car. It wouldn't stop him from charging from his solar system and he could also charge elsewhere. Also I wouldn't charge a Nissan Leaf battery using CCS (DC) since there's no battery temperature control. The same applies to an E-Up.

RAB
Those batteries would get very hot at CCS charge rates, and no way the car can control that rate, as cars with temperature control can.
Mac.
 
Those batteries would get very hot at CCS charge rates, and no way the car can control that rate, as cars with temperature control can.
Mac.
It is possible to charge a Leaf with CCS but that's why S/H Leafs are so cheap!

RAB
 
My problem with the electric cars is that they should have been small, light, nimble and *affordable*, but all that went down the drain because market wanted EV SUVs that cost tens of thousands. On top of it, none of them would be repairable, they will be appliances with most likely planned obsolescence forcing you to replace them at regular intervals. All this means that the benefit for the environment would be questionable.
You're being a bit selective, aren't you?



RAB
 
Back
Top